Skip to main content

Credit to bold Gatland for picking a Lions side on form not reputation

For South Africa’s analysts it will feel like doing battle with an army of unknown warriors for Saturday’s first Test

Warren Gatland has gone for raw-edged hunger in his selection, such as the Lions first-timer Luke Cowan-Dickie, above.
Warren Gatland has gone for raw-edged hunger in his selection, such as the Lions first-timer Luke Cowan-Dickie, above. Photograph: David Gibson/Fotosport/Shutterstock
Warren Gatland has gone for raw-edged hunger in his selection, such as the Lions first-timer Luke Cowan-Dickie, above. Photograph: David Gibson/Fotosport/Shutterstock
Robert Kitson
in Cape Town

Last modified on Thu 22 Jul 2021 00.09 EDT

The secret of top-level selection is to heighten the sense of pre-game anticipation. If the team sheet can not only energise your own players but also make the opposition feel faintly uneasy, so much the better. Warren Gatland has ticked both those boxes; now we must wait and see whether it will trick the Boks.

South Africa will certainly be scanning Gatland’s selection warily. Not since Jason Robinson skipped thrillingly around Australia’s Chris Latham at the Gabba exactly 20 years ago has a Lions side looked better equipped to make a more proactive start to a series. Gatland has been bold – eye-catchingly so in some cases – and has put together a team that looks specifically primed to take the game to their hosts.

It is a classic glass half-full or half-empty situation. There will be some, in particular, sucking their teeth at the absence of several reliable Test veterans who might normally have expected to start. Conor Murray, Taulupe Faletau, Owen Farrell, Jamie George, Mako Vunipola … all featured prominently in the 2017 Test series against the All Blacks. If nothing else, they would have known what to expect.

But Gatland, to his credit, has picked largely on form not reputation. After three previous Lions tours he knows that winning this kind of series is about getting ahead of the curve. There is no point in playing safe until the final Test, when all may be lost already. In recent days he has spoken frequently about gut feeling: if the 2021 Lions are going to fall short they are not going to do so with a whimper.

Quick Guide

Gatland's biggest ever Lions calls

Show

Dropping O'Driscoll for third Test (2013)

Gatland knew a backlash was coming when he decided to leave Brian O’Driscoll, a former Lions captain taking part in his fourth tour, out of the squad completely for the decider in Australia. But he did not anticipate quite how ferocious it would be. "There was an extraordinary level of hostility to the decision, way beyond anything I’d ever encountered," he recalled. "It was wild, vicious and, in my view at least, miles over the top.” Gatland was ultimately vindicated with Jonathan Davies shining alongside Jamie Roberts in midfield as the Lions won 41-16.

Naming O’Mahony captain for first Test (2017)

The tour captain Sam Warburton was returning from a knee injury but with a lack of game time and Sean O’Brien in fine form at openside, Gatland left Warburton on the bench and made Peter O'Mahony the captain after the Irishman impressed in the warm-ups. It would be harsh to say it backfired but O’Mahony did not exactly shine in the 30-15 defeat and dropped out of the squad altogether for the two subsequent Tests.

Pairing Sexton and Farrell in second Test (2017)

Those close to the squad believe twin playmakers were at the heart of Gatland’s plans all along in New Zealand but Johnny Sexton was not 100% for the first Test and Ben Te’o had been a revelation at inside-centre. Gatland has the courage of his convictions but equally is willing to change things if they are not working and after Te’o failed to make much of a dent, Owen Farrell moved to 12 and in came Sexton to prise open the All Blacks defence in a 24-21 victory in Wellington.  

Photograph: David Davies/PA
Was this helpful?

And so he has gone for it, hoping some unfamiliar but potentially exciting combinations will click. Ali Price and Dan Biggar, for example, will be expected to shape a Lions Test together despite not having previously started a single game together on this tour. It is the same with the front-row, second-row and back-row combinations, as well as the back three. For South Africa’s analysts it will almost feel like doing battle with an army of unknown warriors.

Those elements of surprise and unfamiliarity can work both ways, of course. But Gatland is nobody’s fool. Why wait to be monstered by the Springbok pack as England were in the 2019 World Cup final? Better, surely, to try and run the big beasts around and not allow them to settle.

It will also require a solid set-piece but this looks a Lions side well-equipped to contest the aerial battle that is bound to ensue. Biggar is outstanding in the air, as is Anthony Watson, while Elliot Daly and Stuart Hogg – more so than some of their rivals – possess raking long boots which will assist the territorial cause.

And, if in doubt, Gatland has gone for a little lead piping as well. Everyone knows what a brilliant player Cheslin Kolbe is but how much will he relish the thundering locomotive that is Duhan van der Merwe bearing down on him? If the Lions do find themselves with a tap penalty five metres out from the opposition line, who in world rugby would you most like to see with the ball? The answer, at least in the northern hemisphere, is either Luke Cowan-Dickie or Sam Simmonds, both so adept at crashing low and hard beneath bigger men. Eddie Jones does not seem to much like the way Exeter play but Gatland, another ex-hooker, is clearly a fan.

Warren Gatland
British & Irish Lions coach Warren Gatland has put together a Test team that looks specifically primed to take the game to their hosts, South Africa. Photograph: Dan Sheridan/Inpho/Shutterstock

Fearlessly nailing his colours to high-profile masts, of course, is Gatland’s speciality. Just as the great Brian O’Driscoll was ultimately treated exactly the same as any other player prior to the final Test in Australia 2013, so Murray, Faletau, George and Farrell have discovered there are no sacred cows in this environment.

In the cold light of a Cape winter’s day, though, have any of them done enough on this tour to make Gatland’s mind up for him? Murray may have been nominated as the stand-in captain after Alun Wyn Jones dislocated his shoulder but he has largely been sluggish in South Africa. Faletau and George remain outstanding international forwards but both have now turned 30. Maybe Gatland has detected more raw-edged hunger in his slightly younger first-time Lions, Jack Conan and Cowan-Dickie.

Quick Guide

South Africa v British & Irish Lions - first Test XVs

Show

South Africa: W Le Roux; C Kolbe, L Am, D De Allende, M Mapimpi; H Pollard, F De Klerk; O Nché, B Mbonambi, T Nyakane, E Etzebeth, F Mostert, S Kolisi (c), P-S du Toit, K Smith.Replacements: M Marx, S Kitshoff, F Malherbe, L De Jager, R Elstadt, H Jantjies, E Jantjies, D Willemse.-

Lions: S Hogg; A Watson, Elliot Daly, R Henshaw, D van der Merwe; D Biggar, A Price; W Jones, L Cowan-Dickie, T Furlong, M Itoje, AW Jones, C Lawes, T Curry, J Conan. Replacements: K Owens, R Sutherland, K Sinckler, T Beirne, H Watson, C Murray, O Farrell, L Williams.

Was this helpful?

He has also trusted the evidence of his own eyes with Daly, who has not started at 13 for England since November 2016. The Saracens back has looked infinitely happier in his old preferred position and has the range of skills to complement his midfield partner Robbie Henshaw’s feisty all-round attributes. If Chris Harris and Josh Adams have reason to feel slightly aggrieved at missing out, their chance may well come at some stage.

Perhaps Gatland’s biggest punt of all, though, is on the man set to lead the Lions out on Saturday to meet their destiny. What a story it would be if Alun Wyn “Lazarus” Jones could guide his team to the promised land of a series victory; how desperately disappointing, on the other hand, will it be if his tender shoulder buckles again beneath the full force of a pumped-up Springbok pack.

The Breakdown: sign up and get our weekly rugby union email.

It is just one of any number of calculated gambles made by a head coach who long ago came to realise that rugby history seldom favours the indecisive selector. Gatland, accordingly, has given the dice a vigorous roll and now it is down to his chosen men to repay that faith.